SuperWhisper vs Aqua Voice vs Ottex AI
SuperWhisper processes everything offline. Aqua Voice is fully cloud-based. Ottex AI offers cloud quality with transparent pricing. Which approach is right for you?
TL;DR — The Verdict
This comparison pits fundamentally different approaches: SuperWhisper's offline-first privacy vs Aqua Voice's cloud convenience vs Ottex AI's flexible cloud with transparent pricing. SuperWhisper wins for maximum privacy, Aqua Voice for cross-platform reach, and Ottex AI for the best balance of features, quality, and value.
Best for Privacy
SuperWhisper — 100% offline, your voice never leaves your device
Best Cross-Platform
Aqua Voice — Mac, Windows, browser extension support
Best Overall Value
Ottex AI — Cloud quality, voice corrections, inline AI, ~$3/mo
Quick Comparison
A high-level overview of the key differences between these three voice-to-text apps.
| Feature | SuperWhisper | Aqua Voice | Ottex AI |
|---|---|---|---|
| Processing | 100% Offline | Cloud | Cloud (your provider) |
| Monthly Price | $8.49/mo or $249 lifetime | $8/mo | ~$1-3/mo (BYOK) |
| Voice Corrections | |||
| Inline AI Commands | |||
| Windows Support | |||
| Browser Extension | |||
| Custom AI Modes | |||
| Transcribe Audio Files | |||
| Native App |
Pricing & Value
SuperWhisper offers both subscription ($8.49/month) and lifetime ($249) options. The lifetime license is appealing for long-term users—it pays for itself versus subscriptions in about 30 months.
Aqua Voice charges $8/month with a limited free trial. There's no lifetime option, so you're locked into the subscription model.
Ottex AI's BYOK model typically costs $1-3/month for active users. You connect your own API key (OpenRouter, Google, etc.) and pay only for actual usage. For many users, this is 3-5x cheaper than either competitor.
| Feature | SuperWhisper | Aqua Voice | Ottex AI |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly Subscription | $8.49/mo | $8/mo | ~$1-3/mo (usage-based) |
| Annual Cost | $84.99/year | $96/year | ~$12-36/year |
| Lifetime Option | $249 | N/A (pay-per-use) | |
| Free Tier | 15 min Pro trial | 1,000 words | Unlimited (BYOK) |
“Around 10 USD per month—I'm looking for cheaper API alternatives.”— Hacker News user comparing dictation apps
Verdict: Best Value
Ottex AI offers the best ongoing value at ~$1-3/month. SuperWhisper's $249 lifetime is good for long-term offline users. Aqua Voice's subscription model offers no escape from recurring costs.
Transcription Quality
This is where the offline vs cloud tradeoff matters most. SuperWhisper uses OpenAI's Whisper models running locally on your Mac. Quality depends on which model size you choose (Nano, Fast, Pro, Ultra) and your hardware.
Aqua Voice and Ottex AI use cloud processing, which generally delivers better accuracy especially for technical vocabulary, non-native accents, and challenging audio. Cloud models have been trained on vastly more data.
SuperWhisper's larger models (Pro, Ultra) approach cloud quality but require significant processing time on older Macs. If you have an M1/M2/M3 Mac, the experience is better, but it's still not quite cloud-level for edge cases.
| Feature | SuperWhisper | Aqua Voice | Ottex AI |
|---|---|---|---|
| AI Models | Whisper (local) | Proprietary (cloud) | Gemini, Whisper, Claude, etc. |
| Processing Speed | Depends on model/hardware | ~450ms | ~500ms |
| Technical Vocabulary | |||
| Languages | 100+ | 49 | 100+ |
| Accent Handling | |||
| Works Without Internet |
“The accuracy is exceptional, but it depends on two main factors: your microphone quality and the AI model you choose.”— SuperWhisper user review
Verdict: Best Transcription
Cloud apps (Aqua Voice, Ottex AI) offer more consistent accuracy. SuperWhisper wins if you need offline capability or have privacy requirements that preclude cloud processing.
Voice Commands & Corrections
Here's a critical gap: neither SuperWhisper nor Aqua Voice supports voice corrections. You cannot say 'scratch that' or 'actually' to fix mistakes. Every error requires stopping, manually editing, and restarting.
This limitation is frequently cited in user reviews for both apps. For long-form dictation, the inability to make voice corrections significantly impacts productivity and flow.
Ottex AI is the only app in this comparison with full voice correction support. Say 'scratch that' to delete, 'actually' to rephrase, or use inline AI commands to transform text mid-dictation.
| Feature | SuperWhisper | Aqua Voice | Ottex AI |
|---|---|---|---|
| "Scratch that" correction | |||
| "Actually [correction]" | |||
| "New paragraph" | |||
| Punctuation commands | |||
| Inline AI commands |
“SuperWhisper users appreciate the simple app and offline mode, but complain about the need to manually clean up transcripts.”— Multiple Reddit reviews
“It insists on supplying all of its own punctuation. And there's no way to disable this.”— SuperWhisper App Store review
Verdict: Best Voice Commands
Ottex AI is the clear winner—the only app with voice corrections and inline AI commands. SuperWhisper and Aqua Voice both require manual editing for mistakes.
AI Features & Shortcuts
SuperWhisper offers custom 'modes' where you can define AI prompts that process your transcription. Want email formatting? Create a mode. Professional tone? Another mode. This is powerful but always post-processing—never inline.
Aqua Voice has similar customization with instructions that shape how your dictation is processed. Context awareness reads your screen (locally) to inform formatting decisions.
Ottex AI offers both post-processing (AI shortcuts on any selected text) and unique inline AI commands. Say 'Ottex start make this more professional Ottex end' mid-sentence and watch the transformation happen. This 'vibe typing' approach is exclusive to Ottex.
| Feature | SuperWhisper | Aqua Voice | Ottex AI |
|---|---|---|---|
| AI Processing | Post-dictation | Post-dictation | Inline + Post |
| Custom Modes/Instructions | |||
| Context Awareness | Local screen reading | ||
| Translation | |||
| AI Shortcuts (selected text) | |||
| Transcribe Audio Files |
Verdict: Best AI Features
SuperWhisper's audio file transcription is unique. Aqua Voice has context awareness. But Ottex AI's inline AI commands enable a fundamentally different workflow—thinking out loud and getting polished output.
Privacy & Security
This comparison represents the spectrum of privacy approaches in dictation apps. SuperWhisper is fully offline—your voice never leaves your device. Period.
Aqua Voice is cloud-based but claims to process context awareness locally (screen content stays on device, only audio goes to cloud). However, their browser extension requests access to all browser tabs, which has raised concerns.
Ottex AI sends audio to your chosen cloud provider (OpenRouter, Google, etc.) with zero storage on Ottex servers. It's not offline, but you control exactly where your data goes and nothing is retained.
| Feature | SuperWhisper | Aqua Voice | Ottex AI |
|---|---|---|---|
| Offline Processing | |||
| Audio Leaves Device | |||
| Screen Capture | Local only | ||
| Data Retention | None | Unclear | None (via provider) |
| Choose Your Provider | N/A (local) | ||
| Browser Permissions | N/A | Access to all tabs | N/A |
“This looks like it'll slurp up all your data and upload it into a cloud.”— Hacker News comment on Aqua Voice
“A lot more people would trust Apple's privacy promises than they would those of an unknown developer.”— User comparing dictation app privacy
Verdict: Best Privacy
SuperWhisper wins for maximum privacy (100% offline). Ottex AI offers transparent cloud processing with provider choice. Aqua Voice's data practices are less clear.
Performance & Resource Usage
SuperWhisper's performance depends heavily on which AI model you choose. Smaller models (Nano, Fast) are quick but less accurate. Larger models (Pro, Ultra) rival cloud quality but can spin up fans and take significant processing time, especially on older Macs.
Aqua Voice is generally lightweight as a native app, though their browser extension adds overhead. Users report occasional paste errors with long text blocks.
Ottex AI is native Swift with minimal footprint (~50MB). Since processing happens in the cloud, your local CPU stays cool regardless of how much you dictate.
| Feature | SuperWhisper | Aqua Voice | Ottex AI |
|---|---|---|---|
| Memory Usage | ~100 MB | ~150 MB | ~50 MB |
| CPU During Transcription | High (local AI) | Low (cloud) | Low (cloud) |
| Startup Time | 1-2 seconds | 2-3 seconds | < 1 second |
| Fan Noise | During transcription | Rare | Rare |
| Battery Impact | Medium-High | Low | Low |
“I have had times where I will have a long text block that does not get pasted correctly after I finish.”— Aqua Voice Product Hunt review
Verdict: Best Performance
Ottex AI has the lightest footprint. Aqua Voice is reasonable but has reported paste issues. SuperWhisper can tax your system when using larger models.
Who Should Choose What?
Choose SuperWhisper if you...
- Privacy is your top priority—your voice must never leave your device
- You frequently work offline without reliable internet
- You need to transcribe existing audio/video files
- You prefer a one-time lifetime purchase ($249)
- You're comfortable with manual transcript cleanup
Caveat: No voice corrections—requires manual editing. Larger models can be slow and tax CPU. iOS version has reliability issues.
Choose Aqua Voice if you...
- You need cross-platform support (Mac + Windows + browser)
- Browser extension for web apps is important
- You want a well-funded YC startup with active development
- You're okay with $8/month recurring cost
Caveat: No voice corrections, limited to 49 languages, browser permission concerns, occasional paste errors.
Choose Ottex AI if you...
- You want the best value (~$1-3/month with BYOK)
- Voice corrections are essential for your workflow
- You want inline AI commands for 'vibe typing'
- You prefer choosing your own AI provider
- You value native performance and low resource usage
Caveat: Mac-only currently (iOS coming soon), requires internet connection.
Frequently Asked Questions
Related Comparisons
Ready to try Ottex AI?
Download free and pay only for what you use. Bring your own API key and get started in under 2 minutes.